The UK-based Online Press Gazette just released The New Media Establishment — 50 people shaping online journalism. Among the top 5: Rupert Murdoch, Ashley Highfield of BBC, Craig Newmark of Craigslist, Simon Waldman of Guardian Media Group, and Pete Clifton of BBC News Interactive.
Notice that three of those top five are from the UK, as are, ironically, #6-10 on the list (top companies include BBC, The Guardian, and The Daily Telegraph). What does this say about the future of new media? I think it says the leaders of the new media revolution are, in large part, British. As much as my brief-but-brilliant residency in the mean streets of Manchester made me hurl, I did notice one good thing about England: they valued urban art and digital media. Sure, it was nearly impossible to find employment, gainful or otherwise — but, like Germany, they had whole museums devoted to digital art, and they had tons of interactive cafes and techy-themed chrome interior design in stores and restaurants. Basically, they’ve sniffed the economic winds, and realized the future is blowing towards new media. They’ve realized they can either lead the revitalization of the newspaper/TV industry, or they can watch as everyone else does it.
Except the U.S. — we are, after all, ranked just below Estonia in fiber connectivity and #12 (after Korea, all of Scandanavia, and half of Western Europe) in Broadband subscriptions. There was an excellent Bill Moyers’ documentary on PBS that chronicled the fiber developement debacle in the U.S. in the 90s: The Net at Risk.
All this is to say, despite the large number of American bloggers and Wiki-freaks, we’re still not leading the information industry. Is this because most American media is owned by big corporations now, which is more concerned with financial returns than with embracing participatory, progressive media strategies? Or is it the inverse — that the UK conglomerates also own all the media, but their strategies are much more foward-thinking and embrace digital media and interaction?
I’m getting distracted now. We’ll continue this discussion later.